Copycat Golden Oreo Cookies

Copycat Golden Oreos - #Milk-flavoured #oreos for those who aren't the biggest fans of the chocolate originals | #desserts #goldenoreos Did you know that Oreos are vegan? No eggs, no dairy! Although they are chock full of sodium, so maybe that’s the catch of Oreos. Somehow, I can’t help but polish off an entire row of Oreos whenever I have them, especially when I have a glass of milk nearby. And don’t even get me started with Oreo cheesecake crusts or Oreo McFlurrys. Gawwwwww I love them. So much. Now I’ve made copycat Oreos before, but I didn’t get a chance to blog them. They were too delicious and I didn’t have time to photograph them. That batch wasn’t vegan, unfortunately, and neither are these copycat Golden Oreo cookies. But it’s okay. They’re still SO good.

Now I’m not sure if you’ve noticed lately, but my past few blog posts have been fairly health oriented. Not very many sugary treats because I’ve been trying to slim down and I actually prefer making savoury food. However, I had my little cousin stay with me for about 2 weeks and we had a bunch of things we wanted to try and make. Oreos being one of them, among watermelon agua fresca, potato pancakes, and Nutella fudgesicles.

I actually originally made my copy cat chocolate Oreos for her, and she loved them! Unfortunately, she lives in close proximity to Hershey, PA, so chocolate is pretty much rampant where she lives. She is faiiirly sick of chocolate. So I decided to give golden oreos a try. But no matter where I googled or searched, I could NOT find a decent Golden Oreo cookie recipe to work with. Super frustrating. I even searched with “copycat golden oreo” in quotes to make sure I didn’t get the chocolate oreos.

No cigar.

So I took an existing Oreo recipe (actually the original one I used to make the chocolate Oreos) and replaced the cocoa powder with skim milk powder. I could have replaced it with regular flour and added vanilla to give it more flavour, but for some reason, I was convinced that Golden Oreos were regular oreos but had milk powder. But I know that Oreos are vegan, even the Golden Oreos. So, clearly my logic was flawed.

Homemade Golden Oreos - #Milk-flavoured #oreos for those who aren't the biggest fans of the chocolate originals | #desserts #goldenoreos But these cookies are not for the faint of heart. They are suh-weeeeet. Especially with the smooth, buttery frosting in between. If you have a sweet tooth, you will eat many a cookie. Although I’m warning you, these cookies are MUCH better cold/room temperature than they are warm. They were almost too sweet when the were warm. You have been warned. Now as you may have noticed, there are some Hello Kitty cookies in there. Now, I don’t know if you know, but…




It’s possibly the most stereotypical Asian thing about me. That and the fact that I am much more adept at using chopsticks than forks and knives. It’s actually a little embarrassing when I go out to eat with non-Asian friends and I’m failing hardcore at using a fork.

Salad. You elude me with your unforkableness. To eat you without embarrassment requires a level 6 proficiency. I am but at a low level of 5. But I digress.

Hello Kitty. My secret obsession. I dislike pink. And sparkles. And cutesy cartoony things. But the combination of those things that equals Hello Kitty? Oh man. I want it all. I used to have pens, pencils, plushies, sketchpads, notebooks, backpacks, purses, wallets, even jewellery that was Hello Kitty themed.

I am not going to lie, I still own a lot of those things.

So when I saw these cookie cutters in Chinatown in Ottawa, I HAD TO HAVE EM.

Because I’m still 5 at heart.

Anyway, I hope you enjoy these cookies, they didn’t last too long chez moi!

These cookies have been submitted to the EatInEatOut Christmas in July Cookie Contest


Golden Oreo Cookies
Serves: About 2 dozen cookies, 2 inches in diameter
These can easily be made vegan by using an egg replacer and a non-dairy milk powder (or replacing the milk powder with flour and adding vanilla to compensate. Although I've never tried it, but it sounds like a worthwhile experiment). However, using the coconut milk powder may increase the fat content of the cookie, and you may need to compensate by adding a bit of extra flour.
  • - 1 cup Earth Balance (or butter)
  • - 1 cup granulated sugar
  • - 1 egg (use equivalent of egg replacer to keep it vegan)
  • - 1 tsp vanilla extract
  • - 2 cups all purpose flour
  • - ¾ cup skim milk powder (or use non-dairy milk powder, like coconut, or just regular flour to keep it vegan. I would suggest adding extra vanilla to compensate for the extra flour though)
  • - 1½ tsp baking powder
  • - 1 tsp salt (unless your Earth Balance or butter is salted)
  • - (FILLING)
  • - ½ cup Earth Balance (or butter)
  • - 2 cups icing sugar (or more if you like it thicker)
  • - 1 tsp vanilla extract
  • - 1 tbsp almond milk (or other milk alternative)
  1. Cream together the Earth Balance (or butter) and granulated sugar.
  2. Add the egg or egg replacer and vanilla extract, and mix in until incorporated.
  3. In another bowl, sift together flour, milk powder, baking powder, and salt (unless using Earth Balance or salted butter) then gradually beat in the dry mixture into the egg/butter/sugar mixture until you get a soft, slightly crumbly dough.
  4. Bring the dough together until you get a big round. Divide into two flat discs and cover in plastic wrap to let chill in the fridge for at least an hour.
  5. Remove from the fridge after 1 hour and roll until ¼ inch thick and cut into your desired shapes.
  6. Preheat oven to 350F.
  7. You may have to pack and roll gradually as the dough may not like sticking together.
  8. Gently place the cut shapes on a lined baking sheet and chill in the fridge for about 15 minutes before baking to keep the shapes intact.
  9. Bake for 15 minutes until the bottom edges are just barely starting to turn a golden brown. Remove immediately and let cool on a wire rack. Remove from sheet after about 5 minutes, then continue to let them cool on the wire rack.
  10. To make the filling, beat together the Earth Balance/Butter, icing sugar, vanilla extract, and almond milk until light and fluffy.
  11. Transfer frosting to a piping bag with a large ½ inch round tip. Pipe a thin layer of icing on the flat side of the cookie, and gently sandwich using another cookie.
  12. Store in an airtight container in the fridge, although these cookies are best enjoyed at room temperature.



  1. says

    I am so with you on the whole combo Hello Kitty thing. There’s something just too adorable not to love about her and I am so envious of your cookie cutters! WANT! :) Thanks for the golden oreo recipe – I will definitely give these a go since they sound so yummy and easy!

    • says

      If you live anywhere near a Chinatown, I’m sure you’ll be able to find Hello Kitty Cutters =) I hope you let me know how it works out!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Rate this recipe:  

CommentLuv badge